How can you shift your mindset from defending your opinions to explaining your reasoning? How should you prepare for cross-examination before stepping into the courtroom? What strategies can help you answer difficult questions confidently?
In this podcast episode, Dr. Casey Mangnall discusses how to make testifying less scary.
Meet Dr. Casey Mangnall

Dr. Casey Mangnall is a licensed psychologist, forensic psychologist, and founder of Utah Center for Psychological Services. She specializes in comprehensive psychological and forensic assessments, including evaluations for ADHD, autism, trauma, learning difficulties, and complex diagnostic questions.
A graduate of the University of Denver, Casey combines rigorous, evidence-based assessment with a strengths-based and human approach. She is particularly interested in using psychological evaluation not simply to assign a diagnosis, but to help people understand their experiences and find a clearer path forward.
Visit Utah Center for Psychological Services and connect on Instagram, Psychology Today, and LinkedIn.
In this podcast:
- We are the psychology experts in the room
- Change how you think about your role
- Cross-examine your argument before court
- How to answer a difficult question
- Preparing for testimony
We are the psychology experts in the room
One aspect Dr. Mangnall shares about testifying in court is that, as the forensic psychologist, you are the expert in the room.
Attorneys know the law better than you do, and judges know the law better than you do, but you are the one in the room with the expertise on clinical matters.
We’re the ones who spent years studying psychology, assessments, psychopathology, cognition, research methods, diagnosis, human behaviors, and then spent years actually practicing.
Dr. Casey Mangnall
It doesn’t mean that you know everything, but it does make you an expert with equal weight and responsibility for the decisions made in that courtroom.
Change how you think about your role
As a forensic psychologist, your job is not:
- To win
- To make the attorney who gave you the subpoena happy
- To make the judge agree with you
- To protect your ego
Your job is to make sure the court receives accurate information. That means that you identify and explain the data. You explain how you interpret the data, and the reasoning behind your interpretation and opinions.
You acknowledge limitations and correct inaccuracies, and stay within the boundaries of what you know well.
I think attachment to the outcome makes testimony harder. If I need the court to agree with me, then every skeptical question starts to feel threatening. Conversely, if my goal is simply to make the court accurately understand my reasoning, then the difficult question becomes something I can answer, not something I have to defeat.
Dr. Casey Mangnall
This is Dr. Mangnall’s main mindset shift that comes back to over and over again: explain, don’t defend.
Cross-examine your argument before court
Cross-examination should not be the first time you hear an alternative hypothesis. Ask yourself:
- What else could explain this?
- What evidence does not fit my conclusion?
- If someone disagrees with me, what would their argument be?
- What data would weaken my opinion?
- What information would make me change my mind?
- What assumptions am I making?
The best preparation for a difficult testimony should start long before we’re sitting on the witness stand. It actually starts in the evaluation itself. If I have done my due diligence in considering alternative hypotheses, then cross-examination is much less intimidating.
Dr. Casey Mangnall
Opposing counsel should not be the first person who introduces you to the strongest argument against your own opinion.
How to answer a difficult question
1 – Slow down: You do not need to answer immediately. Take a breath, a sip of water, and take time to gather your thoughts.
2 – Clarify. If you don’t understand the question fully, don’t answer it; ask for clarification.
3 – Answer. Answer the question that was actually asked, not the question that you are anticipating next, not the question you think they should be asking.
4 – Stop. Once you have answered the question, stop talking. Sometimes you can talk yourself into trouble if you continue elaborating after you have already answered the question sufficiently.
5 – You are allowed to say, “I don’t know.”
Don’t guess just because an attorney asked you a question. If the question requires speculation, say that. You can say, “I don’t have enough information to answer that reliably” … You could say something like, “You are asking me a hypothetical question; would you like me to take a guess?”
Dr. Casey Mangnall
Preparing for testimony
1 – Review your report in detail
2 – Read your report as if you were opposing counsel or another evaluator appointed by the court
3 – Talk with the attorney who sent you the subpoena before you testify
4 – The nature of your preparation depends on the role you are fulfilling for this testimony
5 – You don’t need to memorize every word of your report
6 – Use plain language, and if you use jargon, define it
7 – Practice pausing rather than filling every silence with “Uhm.”
8 – Practice speaking slowly so that people can follow your line of argument
Resources and Useful Links:
Get access to Dr. Mangnall’s course
Practice of the Practice Network
Connect with Me:
Say hello on: Instagram, Psychology Today, and LinkedIn.
About The Forensic Psychologist Podcast
The Forensic Psychology Podcast explores the intersection of psychology, law, and private practice through practical conversations grounded in real-world forensic work. Each episode tackles the questions and challenges that psychologists and attorneys actually encounter, from conducting defensible evaluations and writing useful reports to handling conflicting information, preparing for testimony, and staying within the boundaries of the psycholegal question.
Beyond the clinical and legal side of forensic psychology, the podcast also explores what it takes to build and grow a successful forensic practice. Whether you’re an experienced forensic psychologist, a therapist who occasionally works with the legal system, an attorney who relies on psychological evaluations, or simply interested in the field, the Forensic Psychology Podcast offers practical insights, evidence-based frameworks, and lessons from the realities of doing this work.