What information do you actually need to answer the psycholegal question? How can you tell whether your test is answering the forensic question or just giving you more data? Why should you give every measure in your assessment battery a job to do?
In this podcast episode, Dr. Casey Mangnall discusses three types of assessment measures in forensic psychology.
Meet Dr. Casey Mangnall

Dr. Casey Mangnall is a licensed psychologist, forensic psychologist, and founder of Utah Center for Psychological Services. She specializes in comprehensive psychological and forensic assessments, including evaluations for ADHD, autism, trauma, learning difficulties, and complex diagnostic questions.
A graduate of the University of Denver, Casey combines rigorous, evidence-based assessment with a strengths-based and human approach. She is particularly interested in using psychological evaluation not simply to assign a diagnosis, but to help people understand their experiences and find a clearer path forward.
Visit Utah Center for Psychological Services and connect on Instagram, Psychology Today, and LinkedIn.
In this podcast:
- Ask the better question to get the best answer
- Domain 1: Clinical assessment instruments
- The issue of relevance
- Domain 2: Forensically relevant instruments
- Domain 3: Forensic assessment instruments
- Give every measure a job
- Advice to listeners
Ask the better question to get the best answer
You don’t have to memorize a bunch of different forensic psychology tests, because that isn’t a good use of your time.
Structure your research around the situation at hand; the more personalized the approach, the closer you get and the better chance you have of reaching the answers you need.
There’s no universal forensic battery. I think the better question is, “What type of information do I need and what kind of measure is designed to provide that information?”
Dr. Casey Mangnall
This is why Dr. Mangnall recommends three board domains when it comes to assessments:
1 – Clinical assessment instruments or CAIs
2 – Forensically relevant instruments or FRIs
3 – Forensic assessment instruments or FAIs
The distinction is useful because each category moves us progressively closer to the actual psycholegal question.
Dr. Casey Mangnall
Domain 1: Clinical assessment instruments
These are the tests that psychologists likely already know. They were primarily developed to assess psychological or medical constructs in traditional, medical settings.
Their purposes may include:
- Assessment
- Diagnosis
- Treatment planning
- Cognitive and personality assessments
These assessments often have large research bases, strong psychometric development, standardization, normative samples, and decades of clinical use. However, they often have issues of relevance and self-report.
That makes them incredibly valuable, but there is a catch: they weren’t necessarily designed to answer forensic questions.
Dr. Casey Mangnall
The issue of relevance
The issue of relevance is particularly important when it comes to clinical assessment instruments.
We have to consider: why are we using these instruments? The reason why we use them has to be stronger than whether the instrument is popular, well-known, or has a large research base.
What does the test add? I think this is one of my favorite questions in test selection for forensic evaluations; not “Is this a good test?” but “What will I know after administering this test that I don’t already know?” If you can’t answer that, then it’s worth reconsidering whether that specific measure belongs in your testing battery.
Dr. Casey Mangnall
Domain 2: Forensically relevant instruments
Forensically relevant instruments assess clinical constructs that are particularly important or relevant in forensic evaluations.
They are not measuring the legal standard itself; instead, they are assessing relevance to forensic reasoning.
Some examples include:
- HCR20
- TOMM
- SIRS
These constructs are very relevant to forensic work, but they still don’t answer the psycholegal question itself.
Dr. Casey Mangnall
Essentially, the instrument helps organize a specific forensic construct.
The biggest advantage of forensically relevant instruments is, unsurprisingly, their relevance. They make the connection between the measure and your referral question more direct than is typically the case with clinical assessment instruments.
However, the tradeoff is that some of these instruments may have smaller research bases and fewer clinical measures.
Domain 3: Forensic assessment instruments
This category is the closest to the legal question: forensic assessment instruments are designed to assess specific psycholegal abilities.
Examples of these include:
- MacCAT-CA
- ECST-R
These can help assess understanding of legal proceedings and reasoning about legal options for defence strategies, working with the defendant’s attorney, and so forth.
You can’t administer something like the MacCAT-CA or the ECST-R and say, “Yes, this person is competent or incompetent.” The measure provides structured data relevant to specific abilities, but the evaluator still has to integrate interview findings, records, collateral information, behavioral observations … This is where some psychologists can get overly enamoured with testing.
Dr. Casey Mangnall
A standardized instrument can feel objective and something solid to use, but that can create a false sense of certainty. Remember that the test is just one data source.
Give every measure a job
Before Casey administers a test, she asks:
1 – What hypothesis am I evaluating?
2 – What information am I missing?
3 – How will this test help address that gap?
4 – What will I do differently depending on the result?
By answering those questions, I come up with a much more defensible reason for including or excluding a test from my battery.
Dr. Casey Mangnall
Advice to listeners
Remember that psychological testing is not inherent to forensic evaluation: testing should be used when it is relevant to the legal question and valid for the population.
So the next time you are building a forensic battery,
First ask: “What psycholegal question am I answering?”
And then, “What psychological or functional information do I need to answer that question?”
Additionally, “Which of these three domains does that fall into?”
Fourthly, “What does this test add that I don’t already have or know?”
Lastly, “Can I defend using this test with this person in this setting for this purpose?”
This is a reasoning process, and more than just an assessment battery.
Resources and Useful Links:
Practice of the Practice Network
Connect with Me:
Say hello on: Instagram, Psychology Today, and LinkedIn.
About The Forensic Psychologist Podcast
The Forensic Psychology Podcast explores the intersection of psychology, law, and private practice through practical conversations grounded in real-world forensic work. Each episode tackles the questions and challenges that psychologists and attorneys actually encounter, from conducting defensible evaluations and writing useful reports to handling conflicting information, preparing for testimony, and staying within the boundaries of the psycholegal question.
Beyond the clinical and legal side of forensic psychology, the podcast also explores what it takes to build and grow a successful forensic practice. Whether you’re an experienced forensic psychologist, a therapist who occasionally works with the legal system, an attorney who relies on psychological evaluations, or simply interested in the field, the Forensic Psychology Podcast offers practical insights, evidence-based frameworks, and lessons from the realities of doing this work.