What fundamentally changes when psychological evaluations need to answer a legal question? When the person sitting across from you is not technically your client, how does that reshape your role, responsibilities, and ethical obligations as a psychologist? Why is a diagnosis alone rarely enough?
In this podcast episode, Dr. Casey Mangnall discusses the difference between psychological evaluations and forensic evaluations.
Meet Dr. Casey Mangnall

Dr. Casey Mangnall is a licensed psychologist, forensic psychologist, and founder of Utah Center for Psychological Services. She specializes in comprehensive psychological and forensic assessments, including evaluations for ADHD, autism, trauma, learning difficulties, and complex diagnostic questions.
A graduate of the University of Denver, Casey combines rigorous, evidence-based assessment with a strengths-based and human approach. She is particularly interested in using psychological evaluation not simply to assign a diagnosis, but to help people understand their experiences and find a clearer path forward.
Visit Utah Center for Psychological Services and connect on Instagram, Psychology Today, and LinkedIn.
In this podcast:
- A forensic evaluation is not the same as a standard, clinical one
- Some differences between therapeutic and forensic evaluations
- Determining who the client is
- The purpose of forensic evaluations
- Answering the psycholegal question
- What makes a forensic evaluation “forensic”?
A forensic evaluation is not the same as a standard, clinical one
One of the questions I hear pretty often from psychologists who are interested in forensic work is some version of: “I already do psychological evaluations, so I should be able to do forensic evaluations, right?”
On the surface, there is a lot of overlap! We’re still psychologists; we’re still interviewing people, we’re still reviewing history and collateral records.
We might even administer some of the same tests; we’re integrating data, making clinical judgments, writing reports, informing opinions.
If you’re already a competent psychologist and you’re competent at psychological assessment, it can be really tempting to think that forensic assessment is basically the same thing with a court order attached … But that’s really not the case.
Dr. Casey Mangnall
Some differences between therapeutic and forensic evaluations
Some of the fundamental differences between therapeutic and forensic evaluations can include:
- Who the client is
- What the purpose of the evaluation is
- What kind of informed consent we provide
- The role that the psychologist occupies
- What information we rely on
- The standards that govern our work
- What we’re trying to accomplish
I’ll be using the term “therapeutic” evaluations in place of standard clinical evaluations, simply because I want to distinguish between it and forensic evaluations more clearly: often forensic evaluations do incorporate clinical work.
I mean therapeutic evaluation, meaning an evaluation that is done for the purpose of diagnosis and treatment versus forensic evaluations, which is done within the context of a legal setting or a legal question.
Dr. Casey Mangnall
Determining who the client is
Usually, therapeutic evaluations are conducted largely for the benefit of the person who is being evaluated, whether they’re a child or an adult.
With forensic evaluations, that changes.
The person sitting across from us is often not the client in the traditional sense. The client is typically the retaining party, which might be the court, an attorney, an agency, the state, or some legal entity … The relationship is not the same as it is in the context of a therapeutic assessment because in forensic evaluations we are not advocating for the person that we’re evaluating.
Dr. Casey Mangnall
This is one of the biggest shifts in forensic work: as psychologists, we’re trained to help the person in front of us, but in forensic psychology and evaluations, the relationship is not so direct.
We still want to treat our examinees with respect, communicate clearly with them, and build rapport to conduct the evaluation, but our role is not to advocate for their preferred outcome; we’re there to answer a psycholegal question.
The purpose of forensic evaluations
In a traditional therapeutic evaluation, the referral question tends to be relatively broad, and we might be asking things like,
- What is happening?
- Why is it happening?
- What diagnoses best explain this person’s functioning?
- What treatment and accommodations would be helpful?
These are pretty broad in their clinical tasks, whereas forensic evaluations are much more narrow in terms of their scope.
The purpose of forensic evaluation is to answer a psycholegal question; that means we’re taking psychological knowledge and applying it to the question that exists within a legal framework … The question might be: “Does the defendant have functional abilities required to proceed to trial?”
Dr. Casey Mangnall
Diagnoses matter, but in forensic evaluation, they themselves are not the answer to the question. They get taken into account to help find the answer.
Answering the psycholegal question
Forensic psychologists ask: “What information do I need to answer the referral question? Is psychological testing the way to find that information, or just one of the ways?”
Testing may not always be necessary, but it can be a crucial source of data and information if it is needed.
The test needs to have a job and not be included for the sake of adding testing … But [often] courts do [want to include] standard testing data!
Dr. Casey Mangnall
Remember that the diagnosis does not answer the legal question. Someone can have a schizophrenia diagnosis and still be cleared as competent to proceed in court hearings and trials.
What makes a forensic evaluation “forensic”?
This is the key takeaway: it is the purpose, the role, and the framework of the evaluation. You are applying psychological expertise to a legal question, and that requires clarity about:
Communication designed for a legal audience
- Who the client is
- Clear informed consent
- Understanding the limits of confidentiality
- Role clarity
- Knowledge of the psycholegal question
- Appropriate use of collateral information
- Citing your sources
- Attention to response
- Transparent reasoning
The underlying clinical skills matter, but you can’t be a forensic evaluator without being a competent psychologist. Forensic work requires us to use those skills differently.
Dr. Casey Mangnall
Resources and Useful Links:
Visit Utah Center for Psychological Services
Practice of the Practice Network
Connect with Me:
Say hello on: Instagram, Psychology Today, and LinkedIn.
About The Forensic Psychologist Podcast
The Forensic Psychology Podcast explores the intersection of psychology, law, and private practice through practical conversations grounded in real-world forensic work. Each episode tackles the questions and challenges that psychologists and attorneys actually encounter, from conducting defensible evaluations and writing useful reports to handling conflicting information, preparing for testimony, and staying within the boundaries of the psycholegal question.
Beyond the clinical and legal side of forensic psychology, the podcast also explores what it takes to build and grow a successful forensic practice. Whether you’re an experienced forensic psychologist, a therapist who occasionally works with the legal system, an attorney who relies on psychological evaluations, or simply interested in the field, the Forensic Psychology Podcast offers practical insights, evidence-based frameworks, and lessons from the realities of doing this work.