Do you want to explore the intersection between psychology and the law? Welcome to the Forensic Psychology Podcast! Each episode will explore the science, practice, and business of forensic psychology through practical conversations you won’t find in your graduate training.
In this podcast episode, Dr. Casey Mangnall discusses the psychology of being a forensic psychologist.
Meet Dr. Casey Mangnall

Dr. Casey Mangnall is a licensed psychologist, forensic psychologist, and founder of Utah Center for Psychological Services. She specializes in comprehensive psychological and forensic assessments, including evaluations for ADHD, autism, trauma, learning difficulties, and complex diagnostic questions.
A graduate of the University of Denver, Casey combines rigorous, evidence-based assessment with a strengths-based and human approach. She is particularly interested in using psychological evaluation not simply to assign a diagnosis, but to help people understand their experiences and find a clearer path forward.
Visit Utah Center for Psychological Services and connect on Instagram, Psychology Today, and LinkedIn.
In this podcast:
- “What is the hardest part about being a forensic psychologist?”
- The fundamental tension within forensic psychology
- Rethinking objectivity
- How can we manage our subjectivity?
- Working through your own emotional reactions
“What is the hardest part about being a forensic psychologist?”
This is one of the questions I’m asked most often. I would say that one of the hardest parts of this work is that we often sit with people who have experienced either really horrible situations or who are accused of heinous crimes.
This means that forensic psychologists often hear horrific allegations or very troubling experiences had by others.
Another common question is: “What do I need to do to do this work well?”
My response to both questions is actually the same: I think the hardest part about being a forensic psychologist is also the most important thing a person can do in order to do this work, and that is learning how to think differently.
Dr. Casey Mangnall
Essentially, you’re not thinking like a clinical psychologist or an attorney; you have to find the middle ground to think like a forensic psychologist.
The fundamental tension within forensic psychology
The space between psychology and the law, where forensic psychology sits, has tension. This is partially because those fields have different goals and purposes.
Psychology seeks understanding. As psychologists, our job is to diagnose and provide appropriate evidence-based treatment for that person. The law requires decisions. It is seeking a decision [whereas] psychology is comfortable with uncertainty. We are comfortable sitting in that gray space … but the law needs an answer.
Dr. Casey Mangnall
Psychologists are trained to think about how contexts affect people, or their behavior, and we’re comfortable in ambiguity. However, the law wants a “yes” or a “no” answer. Therefore, forensic psychologists need to bridge the gap between a gray space and a black-and-white answer.
This issue of tolerating ambiguity but the pressure to come up with an answer, and knowing when we can and cannot give an opinion, is a very core pillar of the practice of forensic psychology.
Dr. Casey Mangnall
Rethinking objectivity
While it is our role as forensic psychologists to be objective, I would argue there are different ways people could show that.
Often, objectivity is discussed in terms of trying to convey that we don’t advocate for the person that we are evaluating.
We don’t advocate for specific outcomes, because our job is to collect data and then apply our clinical knowledge to help the court make sense of that data, and to give the court an opinion.
However, I think sometimes when we talk about objectivity, we blur the lines, and talk about it as if we can be unbiased in the work that we do, as if we can remove subjectivity, and I take issue with this piece.
Dr. Casey Mangnall
How can we manage our subjectivity?
For example, some forensic psychologists could give different significance to different data points.
We collect data, and then we interpret that data, and interpretation always involves judgement – even when it is based on clinical knowledge and training! So, I would argue that interpretation is an inherently subjective process.
This is why we should be mindful of it!
How can we manage our subjectivity? How do we create some sort of disciplined management of our own subjectivity when we are interpreting data and when we are gathering data?
Dr. Casey Mangnall
1 – Consider alternative hypotheses: Could there be another explanation?
2 – Look for data that disconfirms our opinions and conclusions: What else is there that doesn’t support our opinions?
3 – Seek consultation: Discuss points of interest with peers and get feedback to see if you could be missing something.
4 – Recognize and notice our emotional reactions when evaluating data.
Working through your own emotional reactions
This is a topic I want to discuss, since it often comes up as a forensic psychologist, especially when you are dealing with challenging material.
Role clarity is something that can help.
Role clarity helps me compartmentalize and not internalize bad emotional reactions. It’s then this fleeting, transient response that I’m just able to notice, but it doesn’t stay with me. It doesn’t linger; I don’t take it home with me … I am not deciding guilt. I am not deciding the punishment. I get to answer the psychological question for the court, and then it is up to the court what they do with that information and what they do with my opinions.
Dr. Casey Mangnall
When you understand that your opinions and evaluations are some of the data that the court uses to make the decision – not you – it can provide you with some emotional relief. The outcome isn’t based on you: it is partially based on what you clinically offer the court to help them make their decision.
Resources and Useful Links:
Visit Utah Center for Psychological Services
Practice of the Practice Network
Connect with Me:
Say hello on: Instagram, Psychology Today, and LinkedIn.
About The Forensic Psychologist Podcast
The Forensic Psychology Podcast explores the intersection of psychology, law, and private practice through practical conversations grounded in real-world forensic work. Each episode tackles the questions and challenges that psychologists and attorneys actually encounter, from conducting defensible evaluations and writing useful reports to handling conflicting information, preparing for testimony, and staying within the boundaries of the psycholegal question.
Beyond the clinical and legal side of forensic psychology, the podcast also explores what it takes to build and grow a successful forensic practice. Whether you’re an experienced forensic psychologist, a therapist who occasionally works with the legal system, an attorney who relies on psychological evaluations, or simply interested in the field, the Forensic Psychology Podcast offers practical insights, evidence-based frameworks, and lessons from the realities of doing this work.